Questions tagged [probability]
For questions about the teaching of probability, dealing with students misconceptions in probability, and explaining probability theory paradoxes.
72
questions
1
vote
3
answers
400
views
Why can't I teach that picking (un)popular integers doesn't lower Probability of winning lotteries?
Every year at my secondary school, some student always insists that "picking unpopular numbers" lowers your probability of winning lotteries, as follows.
Presuppose that lotteries let ...
- 31
5
votes
2
answers
248
views
The easy and the hard problems involving independent events
In probability, two events are independent if the incidence of one event does not affect the probability of the other event. Math textbooks often have a problem checking if two events are independent ...
- 151
3
votes
2
answers
324
views
Correct notation of a Sample space
From the very beginning I have used the notation $ S = \{ H , T \} $ as the Sample space for tossing a coin once and $ S = \{ HH , HT , TH , TT \} $ in the case of tossing a coin twice.I have several ...
- 1,144
0
votes
1
answer
119
views
Markov chains - how to translate mathematically the fact that the state at $n+1$ only depends on the state at $n$? [closed]
In a Markov chain of, say, three states $1,2,3$, when proving that the probabilistic state at $n+1$ ($\pi_n$) is equal to the probabilistic state at $n$ times the transition matrix, one has to use the ...
- 225
2
votes
3
answers
275
views
How to prove, without the LOTUS formula, to student that $V[aX+b]= a^2 V[X]$?
The mainstream way to show $V[aX+b]= a^2 V[X]$ is by using LOTUS. However, LOTUS seems to me too powerful and out-of-reach for a last-year high-school student.
Therefore I was wondering if we could ...
- 225
-3
votes
1
answer
243
views
Does some textbook on probability use a particular way (described here) of accomplishing the segue into continuous distributions?
Imagine an introductory probability course that assumes the students have had first-year calculus and understand mathematical reasoning. At some point in such a course has explicated several families ...
- 1,913
5
votes
7
answers
2k
views
Should I choose Cox-based Jaynes' approach or Kolmogorov approach to base myself on to teach probabilities to high-school students?
I am planning to become a math high-school teacher and have the following question:
What Probability Theory should I base myself on to teach probabilities to students ?
The classical approach is via ...
- 225
7
votes
7
answers
1k
views
Special topics for introductory probability
I am helping to design a low-level college course whose purpose is to teach critical thinking, logic, finance and probability. I have been tasked with developing the probability section. I am ...
- 173
-6
votes
1
answer
132
views
PROBABILITY QUESTION [closed]
How to solve this probability question?f a, b, and c are in the range [0, 1], what is the probability that the quadratic equation ax^2 + bx + c has real solutions? justify your answer!
This question ...
- 2,384
1
vote
2
answers
238
views
Online Probability Simulation for Compound Events
I'm teaching Grade 9 Probability. We need to compare Experiment Probabilities (Relative Frequencies) with Theoretical Probabilities for Simple and Compound Events.
I want to come up with and Online ...
- 967
0
votes
1
answer
71
views
Seeking References on Deterministic and Stochastic Phenomena Suitable for High School Students
Can anyone recommend good and didactic references that delve into the dualism between deterministic and stochastic phenomena? Ideally, I'm seeking materials that provide a conceptual explanation along ...
- 2,384
1
vote
1
answer
85
views
Discrete Probability Modeling with Desmos or Spreadsheets
In my Finite Math course* almost every section includes a part where students have to create a file (from scratch) in Desmos or in Google Sheets. For example, they use Desmos to plot piecewise linear ...
- 8,059
5
votes
1
answer
1k
views
Law of large numbers as a middle school topic?
My daughter (a biologist) is presently teaching also math at a middle school (9th grade, so about 14 years olds). Now the topic in probability seems to be the law of large numbers! More and more I ...
- 1,778
3
votes
2
answers
382
views
Common mistakes in probability
$\DeclareMathOperator\Var{Var}\DeclareMathOperator\Bern{Bern}\DeclareMathOperator\Pois{Pois}$Question: What not-trivial mistakes do students often make when solving problems in probability theory, ...
- 179
5
votes
2
answers
340
views
How to teach the concept of probability distribution?
I observed that my students do not understand what a probability distribution is.
We do not treat probability axiomatically on the course, so the required level of understanding is knowing all the ...
- 7,463
5
votes
1
answer
128
views
Examples of random variables that are measurable with respect to a strict subset of $\mathcal{P}(\Omega)$
When teaching random variables for the first time, most of us say that it is a function $$X : \Omega \to \mathbb{R}$$ without any further restriction. Of course, a more general definition is to say ...
- 223
-3
votes
2
answers
154
views
Best natural language(s) for conveying, conceptualizing, teaching, understanding, and learning Probabilistic & Statistical concepts & theory?
English can be precise but it is rather 'flowery' and easily gets in its' own way. East-Asian natural languages like Mandarin, Cantonese, Korean, and Japanese are notorious for permitting the ...
-4
votes
1
answer
172
views
Is it weird for an undergrad or grad quant/applied maths(/even pure maths) programme to not teach that probabilities of 0 or 1 will never change? [closed]
Edit: i didn't mean it like this programme should do this or that. i mean other people are accusing me like 'your programme should've had this or that' (actually they're saying that i should know this ...
- 574
1
vote
1
answer
603
views
Best books for mathematical statistics self-study?
I'm hoping to start a masters in mathematics in the fall, and am hoping to find a good book on mathematical statistics to study so that I'll be able to take graduate level mathematical statistics once ...
- 261
0
votes
0
answers
77
views
Code for Urn (containing colored balls) generator? [duplicate]
I am interested in code that generates an urn with various colored balls for an economics experiment. I came across this thread: Urn (containing colored balls) generator?
However, the server that the ...
- 1
4
votes
3
answers
289
views
Probability — analytical results instead of simulations
After students learn how to use probabilistic simulations, what strategies can one use to encourage them to understand analytical results anyway? For example, I'm struggling to find a compelling ...
- 251
1
vote
2
answers
137
views
How can I effectively learn and master Math and Statistics for Data Science?
I completed a BSc in Computer Science recently and am going on to do an MSc in Data Science. However, the only focussed math module I had during CS was in the first year and I didn't do too well. I ...
- 21
3
votes
1
answer
190
views
Not sure what a student is misunderstanding on this Stat question
Here is the solution I presented:
(a) P(G|B) = (5/24) * (.125) = .026. Since you select ONE senior manager, then P(B) is 4/23. Now, if we are dealing with a second employee who is also a senior ...
- 187
6
votes
2
answers
230
views
Difficulty in explaining sample space
I am running into problems explaining to my students in high school what exactly is sample space in probabilities, especially with identical objects.
For example, according to Q6.2.3 of this UIC ...
- 61
2
votes
1
answer
243
views
What story and one-digit Natural Numbers best fit Bayes' Theorem chart?
Some students have sniveled that most examples of Bayes' Theorem use non-integer numbers. I want to try a Bayes' Theorem chart that uses just single digit Natural Numbers $\le 9$. To complete the ...
user15364
50
votes
21
answers
17k
views
How to explain that winning the lottery is not a 50/50 distribution?
When casually discussing with my 13 yo child about probabilities, he told me
there is a 50% chance to win at the lottery
To what I said
no, there is a 1 chance over 90 million
(I roughly estimated ...
- 1,398
1
vote
2
answers
224
views
Cautionary tales for Gaussians/the central limit theorem?
In any undergraduate course on probability, one of the fundamental results that is discussed is the central limit theorem. Apart from the interesting mathematics needed to prove the result (most often ...
- 111
4
votes
0
answers
108
views
Transition into a non-explicit sample space world
This is one of the problem taunting me over years while explaining probability.
In most of the high-school as well as graduate textbooks, there are at most very few lines to deal with this problem.
...
- 259
3
votes
4
answers
548
views
Best resources for probability/statistics textbooks
I'm looking for a good textbook introduction to probability/statistics that a first/second year undergrad math student could use! I'd like a book that emphasizes theory over procedure. I'd prefer an ...
- 496
4
votes
1
answer
105
views
EdX Courses for Self-Study
I have been independently considering two edX courses in mathematics. The first, a course on probability theory drawing from a financial crisis case study, appeared to me plausibly comparable in ...
- 41
2
votes
1
answer
136
views
How to emulate erf and/or the Normal Inverse function in Moodle?
I've just discovered "calculated questions" in Moodle and I'm trying to create a simple one where I would be asking the student to find the probability that an observation from a standard normal ...
- 123
12
votes
9
answers
2k
views
Why do you need to distinguish between apparently identical objects in probability?
In the math class I taught today I was asked a question, and I was unable to give a good answer.
The problem was as follows: A certain factory produces throat tablets. In each pack, there are from 48 ...
- 399
4
votes
1
answer
344
views
The most transparent exposition of Bayes' Theorem
I am seeking the most transparent exposition of Bayes' Theorem (for undergraduates). I would prefer to avoid mentioning "prior" and "posterior," and instead focus on frequencies.
The
Wikipedia entry
...
- 30.1k
4
votes
2
answers
104
views
A Markov chain demonstration that doesn't require computers
I have a large probability class and would like to do some memorable demonstrations of Markov chains for them. Does anyone have any recommendations for a "low-tech" demo that doesn't involve ...
- 141
5
votes
2
answers
174
views
Better ways to explain mutually exclusiveness and dependency of events
I am teaching probability on mutually exclusiveness and dependency of events. Let me take a simple example as follows.
A box contains 2 red balls and 3 purple balls. They are identical except for ...
- 309
2
votes
1
answer
185
views
What does "Four selected students are not born in the same months" mean?
I am teaching on probability. I found a question that seems to be ambiguous as follows.
Four students are randomly chosen from a place. Assuming the birthdays of people are equally likely to occur ...
- 309
4
votes
1
answer
301
views
How to explain the sample space of Monty Hall problem?
I am now pretending to be a newbie student. I write the following sample space for the Monty Hall problem (It is a famous brain teaser, I assume you know it).
$$
S=\{
(C,G1),(C,G2), (G1,G2), (G2,G1)
\...
- 309
6
votes
1
answer
142
views
Why emphasize moment generating function over characteristic function in a probability course?
I've noticed that some undergraduate introductory probability textbooks and courses emphasize or seem to prefer the moment generating function $m(t) = \mathbf E(e^{tX})$ of a random variable $X$ ...
5
votes
1
answer
206
views
Encouraging students to learn probability
Background: I’m not exactly a Math educator, but I’m currently a TA of an elementary algebra course aiming at students of age 14-15.
I found that a lot of people have misconception about probability ...
- 241
0
votes
0
answers
157
views
What is the best term for "probability measure" in an undergrad introduction to probability course?
The function $P$ that takes an event $A$ as input and returns the probability $P(A)$ as output is called a "probability measure" when we are developing probability using measure theory.
I have also ...
3
votes
2
answers
279
views
Urn (containing colored balls) generator?
I am looking for a nice app that would enable me to create "automatically" nice urns filled with balls of two different colors, following the illustration below (actual colors do not matter, being ...
- 133
2
votes
1
answer
168
views
Why aren't Bayesian Networks and Variable Elimination introduced earlier?
Throughout my undergrad, I dreaded probability. I hated it, I was horrible in it, I just never got it, and felt stupid when the professors used "summation/marginalization" equations out of the blue to ...
- 123
7
votes
6
answers
695
views
Neat topics or problems to include in a probability class
I'd like to get suggestions for neat topics or problems to include in an undergraduate, upper division Introduction to Probability class. Many people have taught probability for many years and I'm ...
4
votes
3
answers
322
views
How to convince the following probability problem to highschool student?
I will present two problems alongside solutions, student is doing problems of type I like a cakewalk but has several issues with the problems of type 2;
Type I
Consider an experiment of rolling ...
- 259
12
votes
4
answers
2k
views
Real-world Markov chains
I will give a talk to undergrad students about Markov chains. I would like to present several concrete real-world examples. However, I am not good with coming up with them beyond drunk man taking ...
- 222
5
votes
2
answers
102
views
Examples showing necessity and advantage of emperical definition of probability
As the title, I want to ask for some examples showing necessity and advantage of emperical definition of probability in teaching high school students.
We knew that the classical definition has some ...
- 151
3
votes
8
answers
831
views
How to best explain that the sum of conditional probabilities still sum to 1
I am comfortable with explaining to my high school students that for an event $A$ we have that
$P(A) + P(A^C) = 1$
But what is the best way to help students realize that
$P(A \mid B) + P(A^C \mid ...
- 1,881
19
votes
5
answers
2k
views
Common misconceptions in high school probability curriculum
I am teaching probability to high school students. The material we are covering is pretty standard and includes:
Introducing how to calculate the probability of events, e.g. coin flips, card draws, ...
- 1,881
12
votes
5
answers
1k
views
Moving from discrete probability distributions to continuous ones
I'm teaching an introductory statistics class at a community college, and we've just finished a unit on discrete probability. At the moment, the students' conception of the probability of an event A ...
- 2,223
8
votes
3
answers
321
views
Mathematical Task with Various Solutions
I need to come up with a mathematical task for middle school (9th grade), which involves either algebra, functions, probability or statistics (anything but geometry actually). My problem is, that the ...
- 181