Skip to main content
removed "edit"-note
Source Link
Tommi
  • 8.1k
  • 2
  • 28
  • 59

Talking to some friends, I was asked to explain the answer to the Monty Hall problem (see also here;) .... they were having some trouble because whoever explained it to them didn't do a very good job.

#Humblebrag I was able to explain it in under 30 seconds to most people (winning on staying is 1/3; winning on switching is 2/3 because it's based on losing the first pick, which is a 2/3); but some people just didn't understand....is there any sure-fire method of teaching the answer to people?


Note: This question is not being asked about a math class per se, but is probably equally applicable to the classroom setting as it is to a group of friends.
**EDIT:** I notice that aA lot of the new answers don't understand what this question is asking. Pay attention to the bold text above, and realize that I understand the solution to the problem, but had some trouble explaining it to some friends....the focus of this question is *how to explain the answer*, **not** *what is the answer*. A question focusing just on the answer would probably fit in a lot better on [Mathematics][3] or [MathOverflow][4]; possibly [Cross Validated][5] (statistics). Thanks! :)

After posting where to find other questions regarding directly to the problem itself, I found this question on Cross Validated -- it appears to be very, very related to my question.
(The letter copied in this answer to that question is hilarious, but very telling....)

Talking to some friends, I was asked to explain the answer to the Monty Hall problem (see also here;) .... they were having some trouble because whoever explained it to them didn't do a very good job.

#Humblebrag I was able to explain it in under 30 seconds to most people (winning on staying is 1/3; winning on switching is 2/3 because it's based on losing the first pick, which is a 2/3); but some people just didn't understand....is there any sure-fire method of teaching the answer to people?


Note: This question is not being asked about a math class per se, but is probably equally applicable to the classroom setting as it is to a group of friends.
**EDIT:** I notice that a lot of the new answers don't understand what this question is asking. Pay attention to the bold text above, and realize that I understand the solution to the problem, but had some trouble explaining it to some friends....the focus of this question is *how to explain the answer*, **not** *what is the answer*. A question focusing just on the answer would probably fit in a lot better on [Mathematics][3] or [MathOverflow][4]; possibly [Cross Validated][5] (statistics). Thanks! :)

After posting where to find other questions regarding directly to the problem itself, I found this question on Cross Validated -- it appears to be very, very related to my question.
(The letter copied in this answer to that question is hilarious, but very telling....)

Talking to some friends, I was asked to explain the answer to the Monty Hall problem (see also here;) .... they were having some trouble because whoever explained it to them didn't do a very good job.

#Humblebrag I was able to explain it in under 30 seconds to most people (winning on staying is 1/3; winning on switching is 2/3 because it's based on losing the first pick, which is a 2/3); but some people just didn't understand....is there any sure-fire method of teaching the answer to people?


Note: This question is not being asked about a math class per se, but is probably equally applicable to the classroom setting as it is to a group of friends.
A lot of the new answers don't understand what this question is asking. Pay attention to the bold text above, and realize that I understand the solution to the problem, but had some trouble explaining it to some friends....the focus of this question is *how to explain the answer*, **not** *what is the answer*. A question focusing just on the answer would probably fit in a lot better on [Mathematics][3] or [MathOverflow][4]; possibly [Cross Validated][5] (statistics). Thanks! :)

After posting where to find other questions regarding directly to the problem itself, I found this question on Cross Validated -- it appears to be very, very related to my question.
(The letter copied in this answer to that question is hilarious, but very telling....)

replaced http://mathoverflow.net/ with https://mathoverflow.net/
Source Link

Talking to some friends, I was asked to explain the answer to the Monty Hall problem (see also here;) .... they were having some trouble because whoever explained it to them didn't do a very good job.

#Humblebrag I was able to explain it in under 30 seconds to most people (winning on staying is 1/3; winning on switching is 2/3 because it's based on losing the first pick, which is a 2/3); but some people just didn't understand....is there any sure-fire method of teaching the answer to people?


Note: This question is not being asked about a math class per se, but is probably equally applicable to the classroom setting as it is to a group of friends.
**EDIT:** I notice that a lot of the new answers don't understand what this question is asking. Pay attention to the bold text above, and realize that I understand the solution to the problem, but had some trouble explaining it to some friends....the focus of this question is *how to explain the answer*, **not** *what is the answer*. A question focusing just on the answer would probably fit in a lot better on [Mathematics][3] or [MathOverflow][4]; possibly [Cross Validated][5] (statistics). Thanks! :)

After posting where to find other questions regarding directly to the problem itself, I found this question on Cross Validated -- it appears to be very, very related to my question.
(The letter copied in this answer to that question is hilarious, but very telling....)

Talking to some friends, I was asked to explain the answer to the Monty Hall problem (see also here;) .... they were having some trouble because whoever explained it to them didn't do a very good job.

#Humblebrag I was able to explain it in under 30 seconds to most people (winning on staying is 1/3; winning on switching is 2/3 because it's based on losing the first pick, which is a 2/3); but some people just didn't understand....is there any sure-fire method of teaching the answer to people?


Note: This question is not being asked about a math class per se, but is probably equally applicable to the classroom setting as it is to a group of friends.
**EDIT:** I notice that a lot of the new answers don't understand what this question is asking. Pay attention to the bold text above, and realize that I understand the solution to the problem, but had some trouble explaining it to some friends....the focus of this question is *how to explain the answer*, **not** *what is the answer*. A question focusing just on the answer would probably fit in a lot better on [Mathematics][3] or [MathOverflow][4]; possibly [Cross Validated][5] (statistics). Thanks! :)

After posting where to find other questions regarding directly to the problem itself, I found this question on Cross Validated -- it appears to be very, very related to my question.
(The letter copied in this answer to that question is hilarious, but very telling....)

Talking to some friends, I was asked to explain the answer to the Monty Hall problem (see also here;) .... they were having some trouble because whoever explained it to them didn't do a very good job.

#Humblebrag I was able to explain it in under 30 seconds to most people (winning on staying is 1/3; winning on switching is 2/3 because it's based on losing the first pick, which is a 2/3); but some people just didn't understand....is there any sure-fire method of teaching the answer to people?


Note: This question is not being asked about a math class per se, but is probably equally applicable to the classroom setting as it is to a group of friends.
**EDIT:** I notice that a lot of the new answers don't understand what this question is asking. Pay attention to the bold text above, and realize that I understand the solution to the problem, but had some trouble explaining it to some friends....the focus of this question is *how to explain the answer*, **not** *what is the answer*. A question focusing just on the answer would probably fit in a lot better on [Mathematics][3] or [MathOverflow][4]; possibly [Cross Validated][5] (statistics). Thanks! :)

After posting where to find other questions regarding directly to the problem itself, I found this question on Cross Validated -- it appears to be very, very related to my question.
(The letter copied in this answer to that question is hilarious, but very telling....)

replaced http://stats.stackexchange.com/ with https://stats.stackexchange.com/
Source Link

Talking to some friends, I was asked to explain the answer to the Monty Hall problem (see also here;) .... they were having some trouble because whoever explained it to them didn't do a very good job.

#Humblebrag I was able to explain it in under 30 seconds to most people (winning on staying is 1/3; winning on switching is 2/3 because it's based on losing the first pick, which is a 2/3); but some people just didn't understand....is there any sure-fire method of teaching the answer to people?


Note: This question is not being asked about a math class per se, but is probably equally applicable to the classroom setting as it is to a group of friends.
**EDIT:** I notice that a lot of the new answers don't understand what this question is asking. Pay attention to the bold text above, and realize that I understand the solution to the problem, but had some trouble explaining it to some friends....the focus of this question is *how to explain the answer*, **not** *what is the answer*. A question focusing just on the answer would probably fit in a lot better on [Mathematics][3] or [MathOverflow][4]; possibly [Cross Validated][5] (statistics). Thanks! :)

After posting where to find other questions regarding directly to the problem itself, I found this questionthis question on Cross Validated -- it appears to be very, very related to my question.
(The letter copied in this answeranswer to that question is hilarious, but very telling....)

Talking to some friends, I was asked to explain the answer to the Monty Hall problem (see also here;) .... they were having some trouble because whoever explained it to them didn't do a very good job.

#Humblebrag I was able to explain it in under 30 seconds to most people (winning on staying is 1/3; winning on switching is 2/3 because it's based on losing the first pick, which is a 2/3); but some people just didn't understand....is there any sure-fire method of teaching the answer to people?


Note: This question is not being asked about a math class per se, but is probably equally applicable to the classroom setting as it is to a group of friends.
**EDIT:** I notice that a lot of the new answers don't understand what this question is asking. Pay attention to the bold text above, and realize that I understand the solution to the problem, but had some trouble explaining it to some friends....the focus of this question is *how to explain the answer*, **not** *what is the answer*. A question focusing just on the answer would probably fit in a lot better on [Mathematics][3] or [MathOverflow][4]; possibly [Cross Validated][5] (statistics). Thanks! :)

After posting where to find other questions regarding directly to the problem itself, I found this question on Cross Validated -- it appears to be very, very related to my question.
(The letter copied in this answer to that question is hilarious, but very telling....)

Talking to some friends, I was asked to explain the answer to the Monty Hall problem (see also here;) .... they were having some trouble because whoever explained it to them didn't do a very good job.

#Humblebrag I was able to explain it in under 30 seconds to most people (winning on staying is 1/3; winning on switching is 2/3 because it's based on losing the first pick, which is a 2/3); but some people just didn't understand....is there any sure-fire method of teaching the answer to people?


Note: This question is not being asked about a math class per se, but is probably equally applicable to the classroom setting as it is to a group of friends.
**EDIT:** I notice that a lot of the new answers don't understand what this question is asking. Pay attention to the bold text above, and realize that I understand the solution to the problem, but had some trouble explaining it to some friends....the focus of this question is *how to explain the answer*, **not** *what is the answer*. A question focusing just on the answer would probably fit in a lot better on [Mathematics][3] or [MathOverflow][4]; possibly [Cross Validated][5] (statistics). Thanks! :)

After posting where to find other questions regarding directly to the problem itself, I found this question on Cross Validated -- it appears to be very, very related to my question.
(The letter copied in this answer to that question is hilarious, but very telling....)

replaced http://math.stackexchange.com/ with https://math.stackexchange.com/
Source Link
Loading
linked to specific Cross Validated question
Source Link
Tutor
  • 941
  • 1
  • 7
  • 20
Loading
added another SE resource for answer MHP itself
Source Link
Tutor
  • 941
  • 1
  • 7
  • 20
Loading
added pedagogy tag
Link
Tutor
  • 941
  • 1
  • 7
  • 20
Loading
XKCD
Source Link
Tutor
  • 941
  • 1
  • 7
  • 20
Loading
Question Protected by quid
Source Link
Tutor
  • 941
  • 1
  • 7
  • 20
Loading